Changing your domain name does not have to hurt your Google rankings, but expect a temporary dip while Google moves everything over. If you send every old page to its matching new page with permanent redirects, tell Google about the move in Search Console, and keep the old domain working for at least a year, most small business sites settle back down within a few weeks.
The owners who lose traffic after a rebrand usually skipped one of those steps. They pointed the old domain at the new homepage and stopped there, or they let the old domain lapse to save a few dollars. Here is what Google actually says about domain changes, and the order I would do things in if you are renaming a shop in Crozet or a contracting business in Staunton.
Will my rankings drop when I switch domains?
Probably a little, for a while. Google says to expect temporary ranking fluctuation during any big site change, and that it settles over time.
In its guide to moving a site with URL changes, Google explains that it has to recrawl and reindex your site, and that for a medium-sized website it can take a few weeks or more before the new addresses replace the old ones in results. Larger sites take longer. A typical local business site with a dozen or two pages sits at the small end of that range.
The same guide offers some reassurance: permanent redirects do not cause a loss of the link value your old pages earned. The risk is not the move itself. It is a sloppy move.
What kind of redirect should I use?
A permanent server-side redirect, usually called a 301. It tells Google the page has moved for good and that the new address is the one to show.
Google's page on redirects and Google Search spells out the difference. With a permanent redirect, Google shows the new address in search results. With a temporary one, like a 302, Google keeps showing the old address. A temporary redirect is the right tool when a page is coming back, and the wrong one for a rebrand.
Most website builders and hosts have a redirect setting, so you rarely need to touch server files. Ask your host or web person to confirm the redirects are permanent, not temporary.
Can I just point the old domain at my new homepage?
No. Each old page should redirect to the matching new page. Sending everything to the homepage throws away the work those pages did.
Google specifically warns against redirecting many old addresses to one unrelated page, such as the new homepage, because it confuses visitors and Google may treat those redirects as errors. Someone who clicks an old link to your gutter repair page should land on your new gutter repair page, not have to hunt for it.
Google also suggests changing only one thing at a time. If you are renaming the business and redesigning the website, move to the new domain first with the same pages, then roll out the new design once things settle.
How do I tell Google the domain changed?
Use the Change of Address tool in Google Search Console, after your redirects are live. It tells Google to prefer the new site and forward signals from the old one.
According to Google's help page for the Change of Address tool, you must own both the old and new sites in Search Console under the same Google account, and the tool runs checks before it accepts the move. Google says to submit it for every version of the old domain, including the www and non-www versions, even ones you do not use. The tool is only for moving to a different domain. Switching from http to https, or from www to non-www on the same domain, does not need it.
If you have never set up Search Console, my post on why a website is not showing up on Google walks through the basics of getting your site verified.
How long do I keep the old domain?
Keep the redirects running for at least a year, and keep paying for the old domain even longer.
Google's site move guide says to keep redirects as long as possible, generally at least one year, so it can transfer everything to the new address, including links on other sites that still point to your old one. The Change of Address help page adds that Google stops recognizing any relationship between the old and new sites after 180 days, and it recommends keeping the old domain registered for at least a year so nobody else buys it and uses it for something shady.
For a local business, I would simply renew the old domain indefinitely. It costs little, and old flyers, truck wraps, business cards and directory listings will keep sending people to it for years.
What else needs updating besides the website?
Everywhere your old web address appears. The redirects catch stragglers, but every listing you control should point straight to the new domain.
- Google Business Profile. Edit the website field. Google's help page on editing your Business Profile says to enter the full address including https, and notes that Google reviews changes before they go live.
- Apple Maps, Bing, Yelp, Facebook and Instagram. Update the website link on each one.
- Directories and partner sites. Chamber listings, supplier dealer pages and local guides. Ask the ones that send you real visitors to update their links.
- Ads and email signatures. Paid ads, booking links, invoices and email footers.
- Your own site. Internal links, your sitemap and any tracking codes should all use the new domain.
If you are also changing the business name, keep the name, address and phone matching everywhere. My guide to NAP consistency covers why that matters.
What should I do this week?
If a domain change is coming, here is the order I would follow:
- List every page on your current site, including service pages, blog posts and important PDFs.
- Build the new site with the same pages and, ideally, the same page names after the domain.
- Map each old address to its new one in a simple spreadsheet.
- Verify both domains in Search Console, including the www and non-www versions.
- Turn on permanent redirects and test a handful of old links on your phone.
- Submit the Change of Address and a new sitemap.
- Update your Google Business Profile and other listings the same day.
- Watch Search Console for a few weeks for pages that are not found, and fix redirects that point to the wrong place.
Can someone handle the move for me?
Yes. Domain moves are a normal part of our website work, and keeping your Google profile and listings in sync is part of our local SEO service. If you are weighing a rebuild at the same time, the small business website cost guide lays out what a fair project includes, and the free local business growth scorecard shows where you stand before you change anything.
Common questions
Do I need the Change of Address tool if I am only adding https?
No. Google says not to use it for an http to https move or for switching between www and non-www on the same domain. Permanent redirects handle those.
Will my old domain still show up in Google after the move?
For a while, yes. Google notes it may keep showing old addresses occasionally after a domain change, even when the new pages are indexed, and that this fades over time.
Will my reviews move with my domain?
Your Google reviews belong to your Business Profile, not your website, so changing the website link on the profile does not touch them.
Planning a rename or a new domain and want to get it right the first time? Book a free 15-minute call and I will walk through your move with you before anything goes live.
